Stillwater Proper Menu (2025 Update)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Stillwater Proper, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Stillwater, Minnesota. Situated at 227 S Main St, this vibrant eatery invites you to explore a mouthwatering menu that perfectly balances indulgence and sophistication.

Begin your journey with our delectable Sweet Treats, featuring the rich flavors of a Peanut Butter, Chocolate & Caramel Brownie or a tempting Brown Butter Bourbon Bar, each priced at just $8.50. These desserts promise to deliver a delightful conclusion to your meal.

For a savory experience, try the Loco Moco Rice Bowl, priced at $16.75, a fusion dish that tantalizes your taste buds with its complex layers of flavor.

Pair your feast with one of our rotating wines, such as the Proper Pinot Grigio or a refreshing Proper Rose, rounding out your dining experience with a touch of elegance.

Starters Smashed Burgers Sandwiches Hot Dogs Sticky Rice Bowls Bowl Sweet Treats Cocktails Kids Menu On The Side Seasonal Pop-Up Menu Red White Sparkling Hamburgers Others

Starters

Green Chickpea Falafel

Salmon Rillette

Togarashi Fries
US$95.00

Fried Brussels Sprouts
US$11.00

Seared Bluefin Tuna
US$17.00

Burrata
US$13.00

Tempura Fried Shrimp
US$12.00

Filipino Chicken Wings
US$13.00

Baby Wedge Salad
US$8.00

Everyday Burger
US$10.00

Proper Burger
US$16.00

Kauai 5-0 Burger
US$16.00

Animal Burger
US$13.25

Patty Melt
US$16.50

Smashed Burgers

Sandwiches

Spicy Grilled Chicken
US$16.00

Southern Fried Chicken
US$16.00

Avocado Blt
US$16.00

Triple Grilled Cheese
US$15.00

Teriyaki Dog

Dolomites Dog
US$12.00

Tempura Dog
US$16.00

Hot Dogs

Sticky Rice Bowls

Teriyaki Salmon Bowl
US$22.00

Togarashi Ahi Bowl
US$19.00

Pork Belly Bowl

Lotsa Veggie Bowl
US$16.00

Loco Moco Rice Bowl
US$16.75

Bowl

Sweet Treats

Peanut Butter, Chocolate & Caramel Brownie
US$8.50

Brown Butter Bourbon Bar
US$8.50

Wolf Of Mainstreet

Peaches Gone Wild
US$13.00

Pretty In Pink
US$13.00

Cobra Verde
US$12.00

Beach Front Ave

The Difference Between Jam & Jelly
US$12.00

Piston Honda
US$13.00

Why Are You So Obsessed With Me
US$14.00

Papa Twist Cabbage Off Instinct

Leroy Wallace

Johnny Chimpo

Wolf Of Mainstreet

North Of 8

Kroll, The Warrior King

Hard To Kill

La Belle Vie
US$13.00

Sincerely, The Breakfast Club
US$13.00

Careless Whisper
US$13.00

At Risk Of Deactivating The Ammonium Thioglycolate
US$15.00

Don't Sweat The Technique
US$13.00

Hotel Nacional
US$13.00

Vote For Summer
US$12.00

Stay At Home, Fat Dad
US$13.00

Cocktails

Kids Menu

Hot Dog
US$9.00

Hamburger
US$9.00

Cheeseburger
US$10.00

Grilled Cheese
US$10.00

Nueske Bacon
US$9.00

French Fries
US$8.00

Bread & Butter Pickles
US$4.00

Fried Eggs
US$3.00

Local Greens

Red Cabbage Slaw
US$4.00

On The Side

Seasonal Pop-Up Menu

Huli Huli Chicken Wings
US$14.75

Pork Belly
US$12.50

Mango Bbq & Bacon Burger
US$15.75

Huli Huli Chicken Sand
US$15.75

Loco Moco Rice Bowl
US$16.75

Pork Belly Sticky Rice Bowl
US$18.75

Nero D'avola

Tempranillo

Negroamaro

Carignan Syrah/Grenache
US$48.00

Peterson Winery

Le Champs Des Maures
US$48.00

Ridge Vineyard

Cabernet Sauvignon

Red

White

Proper Cava

Proper Rose

Proper Pinot Grigio

Proper Rotating White

Gruner Veltliner Chardonnay Pinot Blanc
US$40.00

Chardonnay Trebbiano Grillo

Sparkling Rosato

Chenin Blanc

Muscadet

Rose Of Corvina

Columbard Chenin Blanc

Spumante Rosato Di Labrusco

Blanc De Blanc

Champagne
US$70.00

Sparkling

Hamburgers

Animal Burger
US$9.00

Big Beef Burger
US$15.00

Hot Dog

Hamburger

Cheeseburger
US$10.00

Grilled Cheese

Chicken Tenders

Pina Dog

Tito's & Sodas
US$5.00

Irish Mule
US$7.00

J.w. Bourbon
US$5.00

Local Seltzers
US$5.00

Tito's Cosmo
US$9.00

Tap Beers
US$1.00

Others